Thursday, December 6, 2012

an engagement with the text

"What is knowledge?  It would be easier for everyone if rational deliberation always converged in common understandings.  But even those of us who believe that some knowledge claims are better than others have difficulty in denying that even the best ones retain a certain incomprehensibility.  This is because knowledge claims emerge in relation to concrete problems and possibilities for dialogue-- the productive features of friction" (Tsing, 10).
 
I.  Introduction; perhaps meant to build suspense.
As I was reading "Friction" it became apparent that there were* two simultaneous mysteries unfolding before my eyes: the first with regard to the lack of a definition of the work "friction" within the text, as far as I could tell; and the second with regard to the mysterious prior owner of my "used" book.  
I.a.
Friction, n.
Pronunciation:  /ˈfrɪkʃən/
Etymology:  < French friction, < Latin frictiōn-em, n. of action from fricāre to rub.
 1. a. The action of chafing or rubbing (the body or limbs). (Formerly much used in medical treatment.

I.b.
This note, found just inside the cover of the book, is ostensibly from an earlier experience with this same book. 




I.c.
The terms"mountain climbing" and "advocacy" are the two most aggressively underlined statements between the pages 131-154, if not in the entire book, by the mark of the prior owner.


II. Middle

On a certain level, at least in the manner in which I am hoping to frame this blog post, my experience with Tsing's ethnography of global connection in a manner that is, already, a function of the book itself.  

A story I heard recently: (with more and less embellishment, as seems appropriate)
Between autumn and winter holidays last year Jules decided to go visit some friends in New York.  He and Savannah booked a bus from Providence's Kennedy Plaza to Penn Station and promptly left the next morning.  The trip went alright, though slightly tense (seeing old friends who had graduated from his school, friends in school in New York from his life back in Seattle, etc), for the first twenty-four hours.  However, Saturday night, Jules and Savannah went out to buy a bottle of wine.  Jules became very excited about a bottle of wine from Washington State (something about "we were born this way").  The name of the bottle, however, was "Murphy's Law."  At this point in the story we come to a standstill.  Savannah argues that before finding this bottle of wine, they had already been arguing about whether or not the labeling of a situation (an omen of sorts) could actually effect the course of action -- or a perception of a course of action-- in which the omen appears.  Thus, buying "Murphy's Law" wine was a decision to test this theory.  Jules, on the other hand, insists that the bottle was the impetus for the conversation, which didn't occur until later when they were drinking the wine and thinking about the potential consequences of its name.  In either case, both agree that the 24 hours  following the purchase and consumption of the bottle functioned absolutely according to the logic of Murphy's Law.  



III. End

III.a.
Hypotheses are often proven correct.

III.b.
Knowledge works according to its own logic, continually (re)created according to an interplay between new and existing structures of thought.     
- Friction, as a text, necessarily manifests several forms of friction which it discusses.   
- Friction perhaps doesn't need to define "friction" in part because it exists as a definition of it, in full.
- Perhaps my encounter with the note and the words of the unknown previous owner present not just a friction, but the necessary friction for me to properly encounter the book at this time.
- Perhaps the point is not that something had to happen, but that it did, and that we can just except an innumerability in the interplay between the specific and the general; we can accept the conditions which produce the local and the global, not only in tandem, but always also exactly simultaneously. 

III.c.
"The universal bridge to a global dream space still beckons to us" (Tsing, 85).




*I use "were" specifically, as in, instead of "are," which I might usually use when discussing a piece of writing.  However, for the purposes of this narrative, the specificity of the time and place (the physicality and historicity) of the book itself play a key role, and thus the temporality (in this case, in the past) is a relevant feature of the linear progression.  

Wednesday, December 5, 2012

Final Paper Proposal




Over the past decade photography has shifted almost entirely from an analog to digital medium.  By getting rid of film and making the image available (and viewable) almost instantaneously made the process of photography both accessible and affordable.
The size of the digital chips that hold image data are small enough that few portable devices that don’t have a camera built in.

When photography was analog, images were printed and placed in an album or a picture frame for display. Digital images usually end up on the Internet, usually as fodder for comments on social networking sites or as public and private albums on  an image hosting sites.  The majority of digital images never get printed or even contemplated after they get posted online.  Most people assume they will be always be accessible and editable, if a person decides to delete an image entirely.

Now that Internet users are creating the majority of images, how does this change the way people consume, create and disburse images?



My final paper will tie in with projects I am researching and working on for my thesis.
In my paper I want to explore several themes that we have covered over the semester and try to connect them with what I’ve found while browsing the public RSS feeds of image hosting sites.



  • The public/private & annonymity  ----   Anderson.   
  • Friction  --  the Internet as a frontier
  • Free labor (terms of service for image hosting sites.)…. Terranova
  • Affect  --   Berlant and Ahmed




proposal


I’d like to write a paper that articulates some of the theoretical connections to historical reenactment that have come up often in this class. I haven’t thought them through connectively yet—mostly in conjunction with individual readings—so I’d like so synthesize some of my thinking a bit.

For example: I’m interested in Terranova’s idea that representational/identity politics fall away to a relationship of movement versus stagnation and unpredictability in networks. Specifically, I’m interested in the way that the identities of reenacted characters can be assumed/discarded at will, along with the valences and associations of those identities. An actor might choose to depict one side of a war and later another. The process recreates history with a value of precision but in doing so some of the political implications inexplicably fall away. They move through the past.

This shift has to do with a lack of direct experience and also the mediation of the event by time, but slowly, historical reenactment itself becomes a ritual, a practice. I’d like to investigate this folding of time considering, for example, that Ahmed calls emotions “the very ‘flesh’ of time.” Reenactment is the fleshy disruption of time. Ahmed says emotions develop based on a history of physical interaction, of accruing, of stickiness. I want to investigate the practice in that sense—as perhaps superficially apolitical and recreational but in reality a pairing of constructed temporality and physicality and “memory.” Berlant says that habituation—ritual--“dissolve[s] the distinction among and fetishization of memory, history, fantasy, and futurity.” Experience and narrative meld.

I’d also like to investigate Anderson’s idea that nationalism was born out of the capacities of print capitalism and Benjamin’s homogenous, empty time—what does nationalism become when time/history becomes both newly linear, performative, recreated (thus imbued with potential), and, of course, diffused of urgency? The ultimate reenactment resembles its depicted event exactly. Many hardcore reenactors have left the practice in recent years because the “gun rush” – the sound of live gunfire, the unpredictability of it – has largely been disallowed. What is the relationship between habitution/ritual and risk? What is an unpredictable ritual? A live history that has always already happened? Back to Terranova—from representation to movement…

I was particularly intrigued in the way that form worked in the Tsing this week and so I’m trying to work out a way that I might do something similar in my own paper—obviously writing about reenactment has annoyingly mimetic implications (you should see my thesis) but I wonder if there is a way to change narrative/tonal register so that in an enclosed space (an essay, a past event) something is born rather than enclosed?????? Usually these things don’t happen by conjuring/enacting them on the page (ha) but it’s a tantalizing thought, perhaps too ambitious for the scope of the paper.

Hipster Homesteading and the Cost of Being Cool


This week I read an article where the author examines what she calls “capitalistic homesteading” - the growing practice of young urban middle class to try their hand at everything from raising chickens for eggs, to canning. The author Marianne Kirby advises the growing group of hipster homesteaders to not take for granted the value of homesteading, and looks on people who get sucked into it with a disparaging gaze. Though I think she overgeneralizes people’s intentions she does raise some very relevant points, that I couldn’t help but connect to the chapter A History of Weediness from Terranova’s book. On a most basic level this chapter focusses on the gaps of understanding created by generalizations, and the micro cultures which populate these gaps. Moreover, she explores how the environment of Hill people: “scattered bamboo houses sat by small swidden fields surrounded by forest regrowth mixing into big forest” (Tsing, 174) was viewed by untrained outsiders as ‘natural’ forest. As Kirby points out homesteading, historically lives in a similar knowledge gap, and it’s current popoularity reflects this historical blindness. The Urban Homestead Project  spearheads the hip new face of homesteading (they even strongly encourage that unaffiliated websites don’t use the phrase urban homesteading –through cease and desist letters) however this action covers up the fact that people never stopped homesteading in the city. However often these homesteaders, many of the people who actually preserved this knowledge often did so for subsistence rather than appearance and so often hid their operations. Tsing says of the hill people “These are people whose distinctiveness had everything to do with staying out of the way: evading government authority in it’s various forms (Tsing, 174) one of the comments on the article elucidates the connection I see “Two Steps forward one step back… Getting a practice into the legal realm makes it visible and subject to regulation” (from mortycore, Dec 4th); much of homesteading’s actual survival utility is slipping away though regulation (the remaining illegaliy of keeping roosters, thus forcing you to buy a group of hens, and keeping the means of production slim), just as much of the understandings that the Meratus Dayaks possess is being thrown away for a system which fits more neatly into a capitalist production based society.
The shifting use of homesteading towards hipness is especially evident in the case of Denise Morrison whose garden was forcibly removed by city officials as they claimed it didn’t meet city ordinances. Now I don’t know what specific violations the city cited but they did remove a garden of over 100 plants for food and medicine. This begs the question, is it more that humans are unable to address knowledge gaps  - specifically ones which delineate the division between natural and man-made –or more that they are unwilling to accept the broad grey area which exists in between. However there is another important gap to consider “[the] gap between subsistence and market oriented economies… products go in and out of market value, but residents continue to appreciate them as landscape features because of their local, subsistence uses.” (Tsing, 184) however this is at a stark contrast with urban homesteading -  these products do not exist as a landscape feature, they must be specifically cultivated, and even when the market value is high there is virtually always another source for any material in a city, and when individuals turn to this type of farming out of monetary need, the money they can make from it is in all likelihood not sufficient. No, the products of homesteading for the most part are not where the actual value lies, the money to be made is in the necessary materials: chicken coups, canning supplies, and the like. As the article notes, when the demand for something grows, it’s market value rises, leaving those who actually rely on homesteading practices in a bad situation.

article referenced: 
http://bitchmagazine.org/article/co-opting-the-coop

Intentionally Misunderstandings

A question that arose while reading Tsing's Friction is the role of intentionality in processes of engagement with universals, productive misreadings, and the making mysterious, and through which networks of political action are formed. If we take the example of the AIDS activist, Amy Kapczynsk, who organized a diverse group of people to protest Yale's enforcement of its patents in South Africa, it becomes obvious that the wide range of groups, motivations, and effects only gain their power through the spontaneity and non-intentionality of their coalition. The variety and contradictory nature of the arguments Amy would have had to make to intentionally engage with each group would have undermined the coalition itself because it would have foregrounded its composition from fragments. Conversely, attempting to engage each group through a single appeal would require that appeal to take the form of the lowest common denominator, the least defined, the least likely to persist and lead to action. Instead, what gives an appeal power is a combination of intensity and openness to translation, allowing for others to invest in it and invest it their own meanings. It is this kind of engagement and investiture that Tsing speaks when she says that

Universals are effective within particular historical conjunctures that give them content and force. We might specify this conjunctural feature of universals in practice by speaking of engagement. Engaged universals travel across difference and are charged and changed by their travels.

From the opposite perspective, it is difficult to speak of intentionality in the productive misreadings and engagement with universals on the part of the various groups that lead to their coalescing around Amy. How does one even go about intentionally misreading in any sort of serious sense unless one considers all readings to be necessarily misreadings? The issue then is one of translation that is productive of meaning through its interjection of the unfamiliar within the familiar and forcing us into prolonged occupation of the space between. We as readers become the medium for the dialog to take place in.

 But this raises a second question, one addressed by Terranova. How do we ensure the accuracy of intention as it is translated across this medium? Is there some ur universal that others such as freedom, truth, etc. all engage with that allows for them to coalesce so effectively around a single piece of activism?

Ethnic Smell



“Body odor as ethnicity was too powerful an idea to fade. In the mass of strangers conjured up by frontier culture and intensified by krisis, how else might one identify one’s friends and enemies? Everything else could be mimicked, or so it was said.” (50)
I found Tsing’s description of this moment in the Indonesian rainforest captivating. In her discussion of gaps and friction, this physical manifestation embodies the gap between recordable and perceptible. She talks of haunting, the phenomena in which what is seen is not exclusively that which is known or present. This seems an intense when that disjuncture between observable and known becomes physical.
Recording is powerful, yet here the most powerful thing is that which cannot be recorded concretely. Rather, the power lies in an innate or haunted way of knowing. In the Indonesian forest, ethnicity and smell become something that is difficult to categorize or make tangible to describe your surroundings. This reliability on lo-fi solutions reminds me of the closing argument that Professor Muhanna presented during his lecture – that given a set of new, complicated, sophisticated ways to understand the world, or to argue within it, that we can rely on the most instinctive reactions to color our Is smell a physical manifestation of affect?
The description of body odor – elusive, sometimes relaxing or offensive – connects to Ahmed’s description disgust. The performative act of calling something disgusting, perhaps also of calling someone else’s smell as particularly ethnic, is distancing from the object, but also reflects an initial attraction. How different or disgusting is the smell, and how much is it reflective of participating in the act calling out the other? The stickyness of the label  of disgust or the unshakeability of the smell are so physical, and yet are iterated in non-physical ways in the global networks we have examined in class. 

Paper Proposal - Forests, Frontiers, and Carbon Dioxide

For my final paper, I want to delve deeper into some of the issues surrounding forests and climate change policy that I looked at in my most recent blog post. In particular, I want to address the current excitement over a policy idea called Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Degradation (REDD) that is attracting billions of dollars in investments from major NGOs and national governments. While this is a somewhat specific topic, I am hoping to use it as a vehicle for discussing a more general set of questions about carbon markets, frontiers, conservationism, and neoliberalism. First,  I want to interrogate the carbon market model, by understanding carbon markets on Beck's terms of a "market of risk." I'm also interested in understanding the work of affect and imagination that the creation of carbon markets requires. Only through imagination does carbon dioxide - one of the earth's most common elements - come to have a significant monetary value. Only through fantastic nightmares of sea level rise and global warming disaster do people want to start paying money to keep forests alive. Here, I expect to turn towards Tsing's discussion of capitalism as an exercise in dreams and speculation.

While I could certainly write an entire paper on carbon markets, I think REDD provides a really neat bridge between many of the texts and theories we have tackled this semester. To me, REDD is an amazing example of globalized neoliberalism and calculative logic. While the forest peoples living in these countries may see the forest as a rich and social landscape, REDD policymakers see the forest only for its carbon value, which they measure with satellites and other fancy tools of surveillance. Here I think Thrift's article on calculation might helpful. Likewise, REDD relies on a very particular understanding of the frontier. While the first wave of capital that flooded into countries like Indonesia supported mining and logging, we are now seeing a new wave of capital in support of preserving forests as carbon sinks. While these two scenarios seem quite different, they actually rely upon many of the same assumptions. In the first, the frontier must be exploited in order to preserve the status quo of energy and consumption in industrialized countries. In the second scenario, the frontier must be kept pure and forested in order for the same industrialized countries to continue polluting and adding carbon to the air. Either way, industrialized countries must control the frontier in order to maintain "business as usual." In Sleep Dealer, the American government used drones to restrict Mexican access to the water sources. In a similar way, we may eventually see a day when Western governments and corporations restrict local access to tropical forests so that industrialized countries may exploit those forests' C02-storing capabilities. Tsing, of course, will be enormously helpful here, but I also think Ahmed provides some really useful ways of thinking about the frontier as an affective space that I would like to explore.